A Business Valuation Is More Than Just The Number

Thomas E. Kemler, CFA, CVA • August 31, 2024

Successful business owners have a lot of ways to benchmark and track their personal financial situation.  There's apps for financial planning and securities accounts that can aggregate and display the total of all account values to the penny with just a few clicks.  Websites like Zillow and Redfin can give a fairly accurate estimate of home values in just a few seconds.  But, what about the value of their businesses?  For most business owners, the value of their business is a large part of their wealth triangle: home equity, securities accounts, and the value of the business.

In many cases, the value of the business is the largest part of the owner's overall wealth.  It might even be worth more than the other two parts of the wealth triangle combined.  However, the value of a successful business isn't going to appear on a computer screen as easily as home prices or account values.  This is why the forward-looking business owner needs to keep track of the valuation of their business.  If for no other reason, the business owner needs to fill in that big blank so they can benchmark their progress towards to their life's financial goals.

Every business is different in a myriad of ways.  Even businesses in the exact same industry can have numerous differentiating factors that affect value.  Here's just a few common ones: is the location owned or leased? What are inventory levels relative to sales? Is there significant debt?  If so, how much is it relative to equity?   Receivables aging?  Size?  Contractors or Employees?  Employee benefits?  Competition?  Understanding how these and other relevant factors should be considered within the analysis of the financial history of the business is the key to an accurate business valuation.

So, let's assume that you, as a thoughtful and successful business owner, understand all of this and choose to engage a quality business valuator.  Depending on how in-depth of an analysis that you choose is, you'll receive back a report that could number from roughly 25-125 pages in length.  But there's one thing that just about everyone does first: they find the executive summary and then scan down until they see the number.  That number represents the net sum of their main effort in their business life.   I get it.  A business valuation report is about as lengthy as a complicated tax return.  When I get my tax return draft, I immediately scan down to answer the vital questions: do I get a refund or have to pay?  Either way, how much?

Knowing the business valuation number is great.  It allows you to understand your personal wealth picture much more clearly.  It will serve as a benchmark to your progress towards retirement or your life's financial goals.  But is that all there is to it?  

The business valuation report should contain clear reasoning as to the methods, assumptions, and qualitative decisions that the valuator employed.  When I author my reports, I try to be as informative as possible.  Each step is explained and justified, and those steps are laid out in a (hopefully) intuitive progression to reach a valuation conclusion.  The valuation report is not just a number with a lot of blah-blah, legalese boilerplate wrapped around it.

The report reader can learn what factors about their business mattered, what didn't, and how much of each "what mattered" factor contributed to the overall valuation number.  The savvy reader, and this assumes that successful business owners are all savvy readers, can learn what to concentrate on or improve from these details.  This is not to say that a valuation report can replace a business coach or a consultant when it comes to improving or refining your business operations.  However, knowing what factors the business buyers' market has traditionally appreciated the most about the businesses that they buy will allow you to concentrate your improvement efforts in those directions.  

Depending on the service level of the valuation report at Boyce & Associates Business Valuations, clients can choose to receive a Zoom or teleconference call to go into the report and answer any questions they might have.  A business valuation report contains a lot of information that builds up to the numeric value of the business.  Understanding these value drivers can help you improve your business and your business's value.  

_____________________________________________________________________________________   

Thomas E. Kemler, CFA, CVA, applies almost 40 years of experience as a financial industry professional to the businesses that he values for Boyce & Associates Business Valuations. He has prepared business valuations for situations including, but not limited to, business buyers, business sellers, divorce settlements, estate tax returns, generational gifting, buy-sell agreements, phantom stock awards, principal's life insurance coverage, and SBA loan documentation.


By Jonathan McQuade April 1, 2025
Trading goods has been around for millennia - with early written documentation beginning with the silk road to the industrial and now digital revolution - the exchange of goods has led to an interconnected world where products and services change hands between cultures and countries. Globalization (the exchange of goods) started to play a central role in global Gross Domestic Product (GDP): a measure of the total value added from the production of goods and services in a country or region each year with exports accounting for approximately 13% of world GDP in 1970 and near 30% in 2023, according to the World Bank.  Tariffs have been one of the major headlines as Donald Trump entered the Oval Office for his second term as President. To prime the discussion and apply it to current events, it seems judicious to take a moment and look back at the role tariffs have played in policy for the United States. Tariffs are essentially a tax on goods and/or services imported to the United States paid for by the business importing the goods and typically passed onto the consumer in the form of an increase in price of that good. An increase in tariff rates is meant to discourage trade as it makes goods more expensive to buy from other countries compared to buying domestic goods to which the tariff does not apply. Major economies, 23 countries in total, entered the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in 1947 to lower tariff rates and other trade barriers to encourage trade. This is perhaps what makes President Trump’s stance to raise tariffs more controversial. A look back in U.S. history will show that tariffs were the government’s primary revenue source prior to 1913, when the 16th Amendment introduced the federal income tax. Today, tariff revenues make up less than 2% of the $4.9 trillion in total tax revenue for 2024, with the majority coming from individual and corporate income tax. Given that tariffs are no longer a major element of domestic tax policy, what role do tariffs play in broader economic and policy goals? The implementation of tariffs are now primarily used as a tool to protect and regulate trade practices that could injure domestic industry, advance foreign policy goals or as negotiating leverage in trade negotiations, according to a paper titled: “U.S. Tariff Policy: Overview” by the Congressional Research Service. For policy, the potential benefits are clear. Economically, the benefits are less clear. Retaliatory tariffs, rising costs, and supply chain disruptions all bring into question whether tariffs will result in the desired outcome of benefitting the U.S. consumer.
By Eric Boyce April 1, 2025
Dear Clients and Friends,
By Eric Boyce March 30, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. earnings estimates have come down, but are still growing for the S&P 500, but not for the Russell 2000 2. valuations have come down appreciably for the S&P 500, and the good news is that it's coming from price/earnigns multipl contraxtion and not earnings 3. gold catches a bid, and there's a strong bet that interest rates will come down based on interest in 3-month SOFR futures 4. both individual and institutional investors more cautious amidst the change in leadership within the market (Mag 7 goes on sale) 5. foreign ownership of US investments has picked up, providing both a benefit and potential risk 6. FOMC more concerned with unemployment and inflation, but do not expect recession despite some estimates for negative growth during 1Q 2025 7. Regional Fed surveys highlight caution; trade figures highlight front running of imports ahead of tariffs 8. corporate profits remain high; pending home sales plunge
By Eric Boyce March 23, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. volatility increases within the market, market sector shifts, market concentration dynamics 2. with higher volatility from trade, etc. policy, markets can actually exhibit better risk-adjusted returns; consumer inflation from tariffs may promote higher profit margins 3. power of long term compounding - EVEN IF price/earnings multiples contract from here 4. international valuations improving relative to S&P500 5. stabilization perhaps in office RE market 6. individual investors very apprehensive about market, think business conditions, employment & income trends worsening. 7. small business outlooks more guarded, higher prices paid showing up in the data 8. housing supply improving, but prices are rising faster than inflation
Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting March 9 Market Minutes featured image
By Eric Boyce March 9, 2025
By Eric Boyce March 9, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. data has been mixed as of late, reflecting some anxiety, uncertainty and conservatism on the part of both business and consumers 2. economic growth softening, although recession calls remain mild. Eyes wide open, however... 3. other data, including the ISM Services PMI, remain solidly in expansion territory 4. Fed may bein a tough spot on near term rate cuts, given the sustainability of announced tariffs. Desire to cut in anticipation of slower growth may be pre-empted by near term effect of tariffs, to the extent they are sustained... 5. generational look at income, economic power, retirement assets 6. equity market trends, including recent test of 200 day moving average and moderation in earnings estimates 7. volatility up, international return expectations higher than US large growth
By Eric Boyce March 3, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. expectations for growth and inflation both increasing for 2025 2. earnings transcripts show increase mention of inflation, tariffs - but also productivity gains from AI 3. labor market really appears stable at this point - firms are downplaying both hiring and layoffs (except in DC) 4. consumer sentiment remains ok, but may change. 50% of consumer spending comes from top 10% earners who have $1.3T in excess savings 5. peak impact of tariffs and DOGE likely 4Q - -0.5% to growth and +0.2% to inflation 6. regional Fed surveys reflect somewhat muted conditions with new exports expected to decline and uncertainty on the rise 7. S&P 500 and 10 year treasury yield positively correlated for the first time in a few months; 3m-10y yield curve back to inverted 8. growth v. value; international equity has weaker growth vs US, but much better valuations 9. bearish sentiment spikes at the individual investor level 10. graph on expected military spending by Europe next few years in the wake of the failed Trump/Zelenskyy meeting this past week
blog post cover: secure, smart, and successful: the financial empowerment blueprint for women
By Kelly Griggs March 1, 2025
Financial empowerment starts with knowledge and action. Celebrate International Women’s Day by taking control of your financial future with smart strategies, mindset shifts, and powerful money tools.
Boyce and Associates Wealth Consulting Charts and Chats March 2025 newsletter featured image
By Eric Boyce March 1, 2025
Dear Clients and Friends,
Boyce and Associates Wealth Consulting Charts and Chats featured image
By Eric Boyce February 23, 2025
February 23 2025 Charts & Chats with CEO Eric Boyce, CFA. Trade-war risks, inflation concerns, strong retail sales, and shifting capital spending—plus insights on tariffs, government shutdown predictions, and private equity trends. Stay informed!
Show More